3 Best Ice Cream Spots in NYC

By Before the Label Team

3 best ice cream spots in nyc

(originally posted in Practically Standard)

1. Sundaes & Cones

Where: 95 E 10th St - (212) 979-9398

What to order: Get their Orange Creamsicle flavor, two scoops on a sugar cone.

Why we love it: This is by far the W’s favorite ice cream shop in the city. The shop is tucked into a quiet street near St. Marks, making it a great post-dinner dessert spot in warm months.

2. Morgenstern’s

Where: 2 Rivington St (212) 209-7684

What to order: Get their Salted chocolate or Raw Milk flavors.

Why we love it: If you are looking for lighter, less creamy fare this is the spot. Super smooth and since it’s light there is no reason to not enjoy a few more scoops than the usual. We love the unexpected flavors like salted chocolate, durian-banana, raw milk, burnt-honey vanilla, and Fernet black walnut.

3. Van Leeuwen

Where: East Village, Brooklyn, & a truck!

What to order: Pistachio. For serious.

Why we love it: We first had Van Leeuwen’s ice cream when Marbel’s doggy day care (yes, that’s a thing) had an ice cream social for pets and humans. We all had different flavors and they were amazing. We then ran into their Brooklyn location while on a rare Brooklyn trek post-brunch. There were 10 of us there, each loving their flavor of choice.